Ghost Ships of the Great Lakes

---

Introduction

On a grim November evening in 1975, a tempestuous storm surged over Lake Superior, claiming the mighty SS Edmund Fitzgerald and her crew in its icy depths. This freighter’s disappearance marked one of the Great Lakes’ most baffling maritime mysteries, etching its story into the annals of nautical lore. Today, we dive deep into the legend of the Edmund Fitzgerald, exploring its historical significance, the theories surrounding its tragic fate, and its haunting legacy.

Background on the Edmund Fitzgerald

Launched on June 7, 1958, the Edmund Fitzgerald was, at the time, the largest ship on North America’s Great Lakes, and a crowning vestige of American industrial might. Measuring 729 feet in length and with a 75-foot beam, the Fitzgerald was built by the Great Lakes Engineering Works in River Rouge, Michigan. It was a titan of the lakes, destined to carry vast loads of iron ore from mines in Minnesota to iron works in Detroit, Toledo, and other ports. As a flagship of the Columbia Transportation Fleet, it became known as the “Pride of the American Side,” a nod to its significance in Great Lakes shipping.

The Final Voyage

The Fitzgerald set off on her final voyage from Superior, Wisconsin, on November 9, 1975, under the command of Captain Ernest M. McSorley. It was loaded with over 26,000 tons of iron ore pellets. As the ship plowed through the waters of Lake Superior, it was met with brutal winds and waves that would soon turn into one of the worst storms in the history of the Great Lakes. Eyewitness accounts from the crew of the SS Arthur M. Anderson, trailing the Fitzgerald, and last communications from McSorley himself, “We are holding our own,” provide a chilling prelude to the disaster that was unfolding.

Theories and Investigations

Theories about the cause of the sinking range from rogue waves and structural failures to crew errors and supernatural influences. Initially, many believed that the Fitzgerald had succumbed to the giant waves that consistently battered it during the storm. However, subsequent investigations by the U.S. Coast Guard and National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) suggested that water ingress through faulty hatch covers might have caused the ship’s demise. Modern theories propose that the Fitzgerald’s structural integrity might have been compromised by previous groundings and that the severe weather conditions merely exacerbated an inevitable tragedy.

Cultural Impact

The sinking of the Edmund Fitzgerald became a cultural phenomenon, largely due to Gordon Lightfoot’s haunting ballad, “The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald,” which immortalized the ship and her crew in popular culture. The song’s melancholic melody and poignant lyrics helped cement the ship’s legacy, making the Fitzgerald synonymous with maritime tragedy. Across the Great Lakes region, memorials and annual commemorative events continue to honor the 29 men who lost their lives, keeping their memories alive in the collective consciousness of the community.

Ghost Stories and Legends

The lore surrounding the Edmund Fitzgerald is rife with tales of ghostly apparitions and eerie phenomena. Sailors and enthusiasts often report seeing the phantom ship reemerging from the foggy waters of Lake Superior, particularly around the anniversary of her sinking. These ghost stories are reflective of a broader maritime tradition where the waters of the Great Lakes serve as a repository for the many souls lost to their depths. Comparing these stories to other famous ghost ships, such as the Flying Dutchman or the Mary Celeste, places the Edmund Fitzgerald within a global context of nautical myths and legends.

Conclusion

The legend of the Edmund Fitzgerald remains a poignant reminder of the perils faced by those who navigate the Great Lakes. Its story is a tragic testament to the awe-inspiring power of nature and a touching narrative of human endeavor and bravery. The enduring mystery of what exactly happened to the Edmund Fitzgerald that stormy night continues to captivate the imagination of historians, scientists, and adventurers alike.

Call to Action

We invite you to delve deeper into the rich maritime history of the Great Lakes by visiting museums or exploring online resources dedicated to the Edmund Fitzgerald and other shipwrecks. Share your thoughts, theories, or personal connections to the Great Lakes in the comments below to continue this fascinating discussion.